Recently a friend of mine asked me for advice. His younger brother had just finished BTech (BS equivalent) in Computer Science and wanted to know whether he should accept a job or pursue an MBA right away.
My answer was: It depends.
Many of us (especially with Science, Engineering or Technology background) face similar dilemma at some point of time in our lives. We’re faced with this choice either in our college years or when we have added years of experience and it is time to move up the ladder.
Let me share my experience in this regard. Right after high school, my priority was to pursue a college major that would get me a good paying job. I was quiet content seeing myself as an Engineer or a Technologist working for a Fortune 500 company. Plus, a reputed MBA in Australia would require few years of working experience. So it was a blessing in disguise that I had to join the workforce after my undergrad.
Life was good in many ways working as an Independent Consultant for Fortune 100 companies in the US. An MBA seemed a Perfect Fit in my late twenties, especially when I was playing a key role on some of the high visibility projects for Wall St majors like Merrill Lynch, Credit Suisse and Deutsche Bank. So I spent quiet a bit of time looking at various MBA programs. The key criteria were: It had to be in at least Top 20 (if not Top 5) and with some campus setting. Based on this, I zeroed in on: Wharton and NYU (Stern), they had good reputation on Wall St. Wharton, though very tempting, came with more commitment in terms of time and money. NYU seemed more practical and I was about to pull the trigger.
But something stopped me, a voice buried deep in me cautioned. Though I was all gung ho about it, that voice made me ask some important questions:
- Will I be ok with the increased responsibilities when I move up the ladder?
- Will I have enough time for contemplation, meditation and relaxation?
- Am I ready to sacrifice some of the values that I consider close to my heart?
Observing the lifestyle (work and personal) of senior managers (Executive Management), I knew it wasn’t me, especially in the long run. I wasn’t ready to put up with the increased stress, pressure, schmoozing, having less time for my family, hobbies and interests. I’m happy that I didn’t take that route and instead I got to focus and spend my time/energy on more valuable things.
So if you want more money, challenges, power (that a Top MBA program might offer), make sure you’re ready for the baggage that comes with it. This is for the experienced professionals.
The ones that have just graduated, my suggestion is to work for few years. Get a taste of the real world first, see what you really like to do, what you’re good at and then decide.
I love your questions, Vic! While I agree with you, my approach regarding the MBA is slightly different. 🙂 It focuses the mind on what you learned, creates patterns of thoughts that will be so entangled that your intuition and creativity get less chances to “survive” in such environment. And I belief these are the biggest gifts life gave us. They are so important that we can solve problems … without having an MBA. 🙂
Thanks Gabriela for the detailed feedback.
It is an interesting and important aspect, we learn it by experience in most cases..:-)